Currently Reading:
Student Privacy Issues--Gender Identity & Sexual Orientation

Student Privacy Issues--Gender Identity & Sexual Orientation

A discussion on student privacy issues.

School officials should be mindful of privacy issues as they relate to students’ gender identity and sexual orientation and how those issues might be communicated to parents. The question of whether students have a right to have those statuses kept from their parents is one to consider carefully in the school setting and to be clearly communicated with school employees.

There is no clear answer, and a lot will depend on the circumstances of each case. For example, the age of the student in question is a factor. A much younger student expressing a gender identity other than the sex assigned to him/her at birth might warrant parental involvement due to developmental issues surrounding the situation. In that event, there might be a real and important need to communicate with parents regarding restroom facility accommodation, possible bullying and the like.

Contrast this with a high school student who has discussed the issue with the school counselor but does not wish for the parents to know and for whom there do not appear to be any safety concerns or risks at school. Under those circumstances, it might even pose a risk of harm to the student if the family is likely to reject his/her transgender status.

On the other hand, suppose the high school student, in discussions with the school counselor, has expressed that he/she is so distraught by being transgender and not able to openly express him/herself as the preferred gender identity that he/she wants to commit suicide. That is much more likely to be a case where the district has the responsibility for getting the parents involved if it is likely that the student might harm him/herself if additional help is not sought.

It is very important to approach these privacy issues with caution so that the interests and well-being of the student are balanced with the rights of the parents to know. Please contact me with any questions that may arise.

Terri Thomas

Legal Services

Terri Thomas serves as Director of Legal Services for OPSRC. Ms. Thomas is an attorney practicing exclusively in the area of Oklahoma school law, with a primary focus on rural and smaller school districts. Prior to OPSRC, she served as legal counsel for the Organization of Rural Oklahoma Schools (OROS).

You may also like...

Bathroom Business

Guidance from the U.S. Department of Education’s Office for Civil Rights (OCR) and Department of Justice (DOJ), coupled with strong support from President Obama, with respect to the rights of transgendered students in public schools, has sparked a political firestorm.

Read More
May 4-10 #oklaed News Brief

A collection of Oklahoma education-related news of the week.

Read More
The Effect of Funding Shortages on Ad Valorem-Poor Districts

Funding for public schools in Oklahoma is a hot topic and for good reason. The State Department of Education (SDE) has issued a record number of emergency teacher certifications this year, and it seems each day brings a new story of teachers leaving Oklahoma for better pay in neighboring states.

Read More
Diversifying Our PD Efforts

In an effort to meet the ever-changing needs of our members, the Teaching & Learning team works hard to offer diverse, focused services that are, as always, free! Besides our online courses, twice-a-month webinars and our customized on-site professional development, we offer five regional professional developments over two days, five times a year.

Read More

Join in on the conversation